The FastDay Forum

Weight Maintenance

33 posts Page 3 of 3
I am one of the few on this thread who support 6:1 over 5:2 for weight maintenance, but that is not to say that everyone should follow that lead as I am only doing what works for me which might not necessarily be what works for others on this forum. Firstly, I don't like the idea of possibly having to fast for two days every week for the rest of my life, and I am the kind of person who would therefore, just get fed up with fasting after a while especially when I don't need to lose any more weight.

A 6:1 routine therefore solves that boredom with fasting, as I no longer having to fast as often. Furthermore, the fact that I am combining my 6:1 routine with daily weigh-ins means that I am also in control with the outcome of that, which therefore means that 6:1 has a much better chance of working with that. By tracking what happens with my daily weigh-ins, I can then re-act to too big a weight gain by having a reduced calorie day on the following day, without that necessarily having to be a full fasting day.

The beginning of this week has already proved to be a good example of that because after fasting on Monday and losing 4 pounds with that, I then over-indulged a bit on Tuesday and gained three of those four pounds back again. I then reacted to that by having a reduced calorie day yesterday with a calorie intake which wasn't low enough to make it a full fasting day, but which was still enough for me to lose those three pounds again (in fact, my current weight is now 0.2kg less than what it was after my actual fasting day on Monday).

That means that I can now relax into a full feeding day today and if I gain too much weight with that again, I can then have another reduced calorie day tomorrow similar to what I had yesterday, before relaxing a bit more over the weekend with a similar calorie intake to last weekend. I am confident that this will be enough to maintain my current maintenance weight range. That therefore means that it is really on on three days of every week where I am having to be cautious about my calorie intake (including my Monday fasting day) which is no more than the number of days per week where those who are doing 4:3 are having to be careful about their calorie intake.

That is of course, one day more than what would be the case with 5:2 but since those who are doing 4:3 can very happily live with being careful on three days per week, I can also happily do likewise because at the end of the day, that also means that I am less likely to over-indulge on five days of any week, in any case than what would be the case with 5:2.
Oh grrr! I typed a nice long reply to FatDog's helpful suggestions about carbs before bedtime and it disappeared before I could send it!!

Anyway, thanks for taking time FatDog, I suspect it could have been the hour long run I did the afternoon before (I've been building up with 20-30 min runs but just went for it on Tuesday) and my spag bol for dinner (with yes, white pasta!) didn't touch the sides.

Traditionally it has not mattered if I have carbs for dinner - sometimes I am hungry when I wake up, sometimes not. Last weds I had had a huge curry with rice (white, we had no brown left) and homemade naan (made with, you guessed it, white flour) the night before and I was barely troubled by a rumble all day.

I am noticing that I am starting to get the dreaded 'bloat' more than I ever used to after eating something heavily carb-based (home made pizza - *sob*) so I do think I need to reduce the amount I eat as I've noticed that I've been eating more sugary carbs too recently (maybe it's a winter comfort thing) which can trigger the 'bottomless pit' eating patterns. Usually carbs with a balanced evening meal including protein don't make me feel hungry shortly afterwards and have no effect on hunger levels the following day. Or maybe they do - I will monitor this!

I've also seen stuff saying that eating carbs in the evening could help you feel sleepy and since I do occasionally suffer with insomnia (and find it very hard to get to sleep on a fast day, which are often low-carb), I feel there could be something in this.

But we're all different. My husband swears by low-fat high carb eating (think bowl brimming with fruit & fibre topped with banana as his go-to breakfast) and will NOT feel full unless he has had plenty of carbs. Mind you he's 6'2 and 10.5 stone of pure muscle so he has a pretty high metabolism!

Anyway, as we have all said, the beauty of doing this is that, just because I did not fast successfully on weds, it doesn't mean I have 'failed' - I did Monday and I will aim for tomorrow too (I've had a giant green smoothie this morning) and hey if I don't do tomorrow that doesn't matter either. Not in the grand scheme of things!
I have been thinking a lot about this recently too!
On 20th December I was only 0.75kg away from my final target weight but then Christmas happened and....well...you know the rest!
Now I am 2kg away from target and have just realised it is quite likely I will be about there when we go for the annual ski holiday - the one in a fully catered chalet with cooked breakfast, cake every afternoon and a 3 course evening meal provided...
Anyway my point is that I am pretty sure there will always be a week of something indulgent happening in the near months and I refuse to fast on such occasions! It is likely I will lose and gain the same few pounds as the year progresses and I will always have to be a 5:2er
I think if I ever find myself under target weight persistently I might have a 6:1 week but it is likely to be no more than one in 4 weeks.
I think we are lucky we have found this WOL and the ability to enjoy food without feeling guilty all the time. I try to put lots and lots of healthy stuff in my tummy but I love treats too... and maybe the odd drink :wink:
I say do what works for you and enjoy it! xxx
33 posts Page 3 of 3
Similar Topics

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 24 guests

START THE 5:2 DIET WITH HELP FROM FASTDAY

Be healthier. Lose weight. Eat the foods you love, most of the time.

Learn about the 5:2 diet

LEARN ABOUT FASTING
We've got loads of info about intermittent fasting, written in a way which is easy to understand. Whether you're wondering about side effects or why the scales aren't budging, we've got all you need to know.

Your intermittent fasting questions answered ASK QUESTIONS & GET SUPPORT
Come along to the FastDay Forum, we're a friendly bunch and happy to answer your fasting questions and offer support. Why not join in one of our regular challenges to help you towards your goal weight?

Use our free 5:2 diet tracker FREE 5:2 DIET PROGRESS TRACKER & BLOG
Tracking your diet progress is great for staying motivated. Chart your measurements and keep tabs on your daily calorie needs. You can even create a free blog to journal your 5:2 experience!

cron